On Becoming a Fearless Pruner

Pruning Sketch

For much of my gardening career, pruning a woody shrub has intimidated me. Fears of “wrong” pruning abounded: What if the cuts I made eliminated all the new-growth buds and the pruned branch ended up an unsightly stump? Or if I cut too much and it died? Or if I cut it in a weird pattern and the shape never recovered? The list of potential bad outcomes grew ever longer in my mind.

 
So I would snip off a few branch ends every now and then, but mostly I would just let the shrub grow as it would. I rationalized this as being “naturalistic” gardening. And this is not a bad approach, especially for a native plant gardener. Pick the right plant for the conditions, give it enough space, and watch it thrive without lots of manual intervention. These days, I use this approach whenever I plant.

 
Of course, some of my older specimen shrubs were looking really unhappy, and no one likes to cowed by mere plants, so I’m trying to rise to the challenge. I started reading up on pruning techniques, and I have learned some useful things, such as that rhododendrons and hollies can mostly be cut back hard and they will come back. Also, multi-cane shrubs, like my red-twigged dogwood, benefit from having the oldest canes cut at ground every winter. I was moving from being paralyzed to merely being timid.
Then I had the good fortune of being able to learn first-hand from some real experts. At classes at the Garden in the Woods, instructors shared their techniques and then allowed us students to practice (under supervision) in their garden. And as a volunteer on the Rose Kennedy Greenway, I was able to work side-by-side with, and learn from, their professional staff.

 

What I learned is that in addition to a lot of experience, each of these professionals have several mental tools that allow them to be confident pruners:

  • They have in their heads a well-defined image of what they want the overall size and shape of the plant to be, considering its current size and its expected growth over the near term. This clear goal of height, spread, and density is their starting point.
  • They also have a mental image of what a healthy and attractive branch structure looks like for that plant. They can look at a shrub and see what branches fit into that structure and which are “wonky” and should be removed. Crossing branches, water suckers, or too many interior branches are good examples of this.
  • They know that the life force of the shrub will push it to grow, even after pruning, and they understand how each plant wants to grow and on what type of wood the plant flowers. So they can do two cool things: they can make their cuts in a way to get the most attractive shape as that growth occurs, and they can time their pruning to encourage growth (winter pruning) or slow down growth (late spring or late summer pruning).
  • They have specific goals they want to accomplish in the pruning for each shrub, such as: let in more light to the interior, pull it back away from encroaching other plants or sidewalks, eliminate older growth to allow new growth, cut it to a shape better suited to its situation.

Immediately, these tools have given me a checklist to follow when doing my own pruning: first, define the target height, spread, and density; then look at branch structure; then take advantage of the shrub’s growth patterns to encourage it to grow in an attractive shape. And make sure my goals for pruning each plant are clear and well-defined.

 
This winter, I have practiced these new tools on a weeping crabapple tree in the front yard. It is about 6’ tall, and the top layer of branches has a nice weeping shape. But I have let sucker branches along the trunk and at the root level go unpruned, so now the tree has lost its weeping effect as all those branches blend together, and the perennials near the base of the tree are in too much shade. Time to get out the pruners and go to work.

 

P1050490
Here’s the “Before” picture. You can see how messy and crowded the branching structure is.

P1050646

My goals before I start pruning are:

  • The target height is the same as it is now – no need to trim from the top
  • Target shape for lower tree – no branches at all up to lowest of the weeping branches near the top. This will reduce the width for the lower 3’ to just the trunk and will let in sun to the perennials.
  • Target shape for upper tree – I really can’t tell if this needed pruning so I will wait to evaluate after the lower pruning is done, for branch structure and for where I want growth next spring
  • Root suckers – these need to be cut back every year.

 

P1050647
To start I removed most of the branches along the trunk up to where the larger weeping branches starts. After those cuts, it started to look better already.

 
Then came the cuts to remove the root suckers. It was interesting doing the trunk and root cuts – because I had a clear plan, there was no nervousness at all, I just went to work removing unwanted branches.

 
I had hesitated on whether to remove that one large branch growing from near the base, and one other medium branch just outside the picture at the top. But they both detracted from the shape I was going for – weeping branches over a single trunk, so they went.

P1050650

 

After those cuts, I stepped back and looked at the tree overall. I decided that it could probably use some thinning of the crown for better light and air circulation, but that would wait until next year – I didn’t want to stress the tree too much at one time. I did trim a few branches back a couple of feet to let more light onto the perennials beneath the tree, but I was happy with the overall shape and result of the pruning.

 
In this “After” picture. I think the tree looks much more like it should as a specimen plant, and it will be a better companion to the surrounding plants in the bed.

 

P1060075

 
A few months later – here’s the “After” view taken from the same angle. I’m happy with the results! The tree bloomed well and I can begin to see how to open up the canopy a bit more next winter.

 
Now, as I walk around the yard after this project, I notice several more shrubs and small trees that could benefit from pruning. I have much yet to learn about specific shrub branch structures and growth habits, but now I have a mental checklist to follow, and each year I will get more fearless

4 comments

  1. Great pruning advice. Here’s my challenge: a shrub that has has 3 old, large, thick base branches, and intermediate branches grow off of those, starting at 3 feet off the ground. My Rose of Sharon has spectacular blossoms with 6-12 inches of new growth annually. My goal is to make smaller in all dimensions. I could cut all 3 of the base branches off, and let the suckers grow (if it survives). I could keep 1 or 2 base branches and sheer the top at 6 feet. Or I could move my house 15 feet.

    Like

    • This is a case where you have to know how the shrub wants to grow! The shrub’s genetics dictate how big it will get, and if it’s too big for the space you may have to prune regularly. The Rose of Sharon is pretty tough, so you can be pretty aggressive with it. This winter at the Rose Kennedy Greenway we pruned a whole stand of Rose of Sharon. They were about 12′ tall, and we cut the main stems back to about 4′ tall. (Pretty scary but that’s what the experts wanted!) They said the shrubs would create new intermediate branches below the cuts and fill out again. You might want to do the same thing. But since they are relatively slow growing (it’s taken my shrubs 10 years to get to 12′ tall) you might not have to repeat again for a while. Hope this helps!

      Like

  2. I can surely appreciate the Reluctant Pruner … I hate to even dead head plants shape a pot of impatience, not to mention a tree! The weeping cherry came out great. Dave trimmed ours out front and it looks pretty good. Thanks to your fine advice, I’m going to peruse our garden, clippers in hand, and have at it … after the bike trip. 🙂

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s